Open Academy Homepage

Improve your Reeds ~


REED MAKING
OBOE CONSULTATION LESSON

Open Academy


If you’ve been following my suggestions in previous articles,
congratulations you should now be able to select good cane, gouge and shape it meticulously and tie it on to the staple neatly and effectively - phew!

From this position it should be easy for you to make an excellent, consistent supply of reeds for yourself by experimenting with the scraping method below.

If you don’t yet feel confident in the earlier stages, do keep practising, it will be well worth the effort. Nothing is more empowering than knowing you can be self-reliant where your own reeds are concerned.

The following method is very simple and I find that most of my reed consultation clients achieve success very quickly by applying it.

Obviously it’s much better to spend a couple of hours together going over the process in person - and much more fun - but the method should also work for you at a distance if you aren’t able to come to sunny Somerset at the moment.

Although there are many schools of thought regarding different types of scrape, I came to the conclusion some time ago that the actual finished scrape really does not have that much effect on the tone quality made by the individual player, as we tend to make pretty much our ‘usual’ sound regardless of the reed or oboe new are playing on. I believe a beautiful oboe sound comes from having a clear concept of that sound in your imagination - and of course, always playing from the heart.

Therefore my general philosophy on the whole process of reed-scraping is to adopt as easy and as foolproof a method as possible, quickly putting an end to the woodwork and getting back to the enjoyable business of actual music-making on the oboe. The following
Vallis-Davies TM method (that’s a joke by the way - I’m not that egotistical) offers one of the easiest possible approaches to scraping a reed.

I’ve shared it with literally hundreds of students (up to the age of 70) over the years, and everyone’s been kind enough to say it’s the simplest method they’ve ever encountered.


Aim to work as much in advance as possible when making your reeds, so you build up a supply of good ones over several months (much more relaxing than a frantic scraping session the night before an important concert). If you can leave reeds for weeks or even months in their tied-on state before scraping them, this does seem to yield better results too.

Use plenty of old reeds to practise your scraping techniques and acquire control over your knives - learning to use the knife skilfully is obviously an essential in the reed-making process. (I’ve given consultations to a number of surgeons here at Open Academy and I’m pleased to tell you they could all manage a knife blade with confidence )

My method involves scraping the various different areas of the reed in a specific order. There are two advantages here - one is that it gives the reed a good strong tone because the heart is left intact until the end, and also prevents the reed collapsing; the other is that as there are so many potential variables in the weird world of reed-making I believe it is important to follow a reliable, organised methods.


Firstly you will need to gather some specialist items as set-out below, some of which vary a little from the norm. I thoroughly recommend them for a successful foray into reed-making.

Essential Items

1. Knives.

I have three - sharp, sharper and sharpest! I use an inexpensive Pisoni for scraping off the bark and general rough scraping, a Graf knife for the major scraping and a Stanley knife blade, either fitted into a Stanley knife or on its own, for the most precise scraping and finishing touches.

2. Convex Plaque.

This supports the heart of the reed while scraping , helping to avoid too much cane being removed from this important area. I prefer the nice, shiny silver ones to wood.

3. Clippers.

Small, sharp wire cutters for cutting off the tip. These are so much easier to use than the ubiquitous cutting block. I bought my Bahco clippers from a good hardware shop 25 years ago and thousands of reeds later they are still going strong - a good investment I think! Expect to pay upwards of £50.

4. Brass Picture Wire.

This is available from most DIY shops and is exactly the right thickness for oboe reeds when used as individual strands (comes as a coil of five strands wrapped around a central, thicker wire which should be discarded). Usually, wire which is actually supposed to be ‘oboe’ wire and comes in reed-making kits is much too thick.

5. Pliers.

Small, pointed-nose pliers are best and are used to attach the wire neatly.

6. Brown Goldbeaters’ skin


to put an end to any slight leaks in the finished reed. In fact, if you have shaped and wired the reed to perfection it should not leak, but if it does, brown Goldbeaters’ skin is the best solution. This is very difficult to find these days, so you may have to make do with clear Goldbeaters, available in specialist oboe shops. Never,
never use cling film. It is a real reed-wrecker, as it is not porous and does not allow the reed to dry out properly after playing.

When you are ready to begin, you will also need these:

7. Perfectly tied-on reed-blank at 73mm, re. Parts 1 and 2 of this series in DRN Magazine.

As discussed previously, you may wish to tie on slightly longer or shorter to take into account sharpness or flatness of your general set-up, when you are more experienced at reed-making.

8. Cup of wate
r to keep the reed moist at all times during the scraping process.

9. Some relaxing background music.

Scraping Method

1. Wet the reed-blank by soaking it in cold or tepid water for five or so minutes. Score a U-shape 10.5mm down from the top of the reed with a sharp knife and then slightly scrape off the bark (shiny cane) above the scored line. Use a wrist action when you scrape and keep the knife moving at all times, to avoid making small nicks. If you find the scraping action difficult, keep practising on old reeds until you have more control (incidentally, you may prefer to carry out this step at the end of the tying-on process - I do).

2. Carefully scrape 1.5 to 2mm down from the tip of the reed, lengthening a little at the corners to make a crescent shape.

3. Keep thinning the tip very carefully until it opens by itself. Cut off 0.5 to 1mm with the clippers, lining them up first and making sure you cut off the tip straight. Then, insert the plaque and scrape the extreme tip again, until it is very thin.

4. Scrape up each of the four sides one by one, approximately 2.5mm in. Scrape exactly the same amount off each side in turn with a wrist action. Do not touch the middle spine of the reed at all. After you have carefully thinned each of the sides, try squawking the reed. It should be making a sound by now. If not, go over the tips and sides again with the knife, still avoiding the middle.

5. Wire the reed. Cut off about a reed-length’s worth of a strand of the brass picture wire. Place it behind the reed, about 3mm up from the binding thread, so that one third is to the left and two thirds are to the right. From this position wind the wire around the reed twice, then twist it at the front of the reed with the pliers until it is tight. Then, push the wire a little further up the reed with the pointed ends of the pillars and tighten the wire again. Twist the end of the wire downwards, towards the thread and cut off the wire level with the thread. Don’t leave the excess wire on the carpet for your dog to tread on - they can get quite annoyed about this when it has happened a number of times.

NB. A note on wiring

I wire every reed I make, as this gives me ultimate control over the aperture and discourages any leaks. This is a personal choice which has served me very well professionally. Some players aren’t too keen on using wire and you will want to experiment for yourself to find the best option for you, but I do believe that wire of a suitably fine diameter is very useful in supporting the reed’s aperture. Most problems encountered with wiring seem to be due to wire which is too thick or placed too high on the reed, both of which will tend to dampen the vibrations.

6. Soften the reed until you feel comfortable playing on it. This is done by scraping over the whole of the U-shape area gently in a diagonal action, from the left-hand ‘corner’ of the U-shape to the right-hand of the tip, and vice versa. Keep the reed moist at all times, keep using a wrist action and do the same amount of scraping to both blades of the reed, aiming to smooth out any slight lumps and bumps as you go. Do not scrape straight up the middle of the reed. Try the reed regularly until you like it. Remember to keep breathing while you scrape!

This whole process should take only 10 to 15 minutes and then you should be pleased with the result, hopefully. When trying this method, only scrape the reed in the order I suggest, otherwise the reed may collapse and sound too thin. (This is the reason for my constant reminders to avoid scraping up the middle of the reed, which is where the reed’s ’body’ comes from.)

After a few days the reed will have thickened up. Sometimes players are surprised to learn that their own, or bought reeds change after a while and need re-adjustment, thinking instead that the reed has gone off. It is very easy to make a reed play well again by washing it under a cold running tap, re-soaking it, then softening it as follows:

a. Scrape all over the U-shape with a diagonal action, or
b. Scrape the sides gently, if you want a darker sound, or
c. Scrape the tip carefully, if you want the reed to articulate more responsively, or
d. A combination of all of the above, but do keep trying the reed regularly between scrapes - proceed with caution.

SOME COMMON PITFALLS

Anyone who is having trouble making reeds is usually put back on the right track by careful consideration and analysis of the following areas:

Ÿ

Is the cane of good quality?

Ÿ

Is the cane well gouged and well shaped?

Ÿ

Is the cane tied on perfectly?

Ÿ

Is the reed well scraped?


The first three of these problems can be annihilated by following the tips from the 2001 reed articles in DRN magazine (and maybe try a different cane supplier).

The fourth needs general perseverance and more specifically, much more practice in knife technique. If the knife is too blunt this can cause all sorts of scraping problems, including damaging the tip or reed corners (very common). It’s quite important to learn to use your sharpening stone properly, but sometimes a knife which is
too sharp can cause the same problems - again the answer here is to learn more knife control. (Not that again!). It’s also helpful to be shown how to scrape properly -the curling and rather subtle wrist action is quite an art to master.

So, in conclusion I’ve probably covered the subject of reed scraping as much as distance learning will allow, and I do hope the suggestions will prove valuable in offering you help and more success with your reeds - and therefore your performance in general too.

As oboists, we are lucky to have so much control over our ‘voice’, so it’s helpful to attempt to view reeds as curious challenge rather than a problem if at all possible. Forgive the borrowed cliché, but a reed will only ever be as good as its player, and it’s always helpful to concentrate on improving all aspects of your playing as well.

Sometimes I’ve found that people who think the reeds are the problem come for a consultation and discover they’ve never actually been taught how to use their diaphragm properly, or that their embouchure is too tight or too loose. A few lessons on oboe technique later, and all their reeds seem to miraculously work...

Anyway if you would enjoy more individual advice, you really are welcome to come for a reed consultation here. It would be lovely to meet you and I do enjoy helping oboists make their playing much easier and more enjoyable by sorting out their reeds once and for all over a coffee in the studio for a couple of hours.

Do give me a call or email me next time reeds are threatening to take over your sanity. You’re welcome to email me any comments too, if you’re happy to excuse brief answers.

All good wishes and happy squawking
Sien
www.OpenAcademy.info
01458 860006 +44(0)1458 860006

N & S Vallis-Davies & Open Academy ©

Administrator & Site Coordinator: Hannah Phillips

Open Academy Homepage

Open Academy
01458 860006